I calculated recently that I breastfed for a total of 7.5 years. Did I just blow your mind? I was the one doing it, and I nearly spit out my Skinnygirl Margarita when I figured that out. When I stopped nursing Isadora last November, Bryce and I had been together for just 16 years, and married for 11. That means I was breastfeeding one of our children for over half of our marriage (68%, to be precise). When I told Bryce, he said, "I guess I am really good at sharing."
Some of you have furrowed your brow by now and thought,"Wait, she only has three kids. How did she breastfeed for 7.5 years?" Here is the detailed breakdown: I weaned Sydney when she was 15 months old (against both of our wills, because I wanted to get pregnant again. It was a traumatizing experience for our whole family). Ivy weaned on her own three months before she turned 3 (the same month she potty-trained), and I just weaned Isadora at 3.5. Don't think about it too much, or you might feel uncomfortable next time we see each other in person.
But wait!! Why would you feel uncomfortable just because I breastfed my children for what our country considers to be an "extended" period? And why would I worry that you would feel uncomfortable? At first I did not want to admit that I had these concerns, and once I accepted them, I was perplexed by them for months. I wanted to write this essay right after Isadora weaned, but I felt... strange about it. Do I really want the whole world to know that I am one of "those" moms?
When I was pregnant for the first time, I thought I would breastfeed Sydney for six months, tops. When I had Ivy, I knew I would let her initiate weaning, but assumed that would happen LONG before she turned two. I assumed Isadora would initiate weaning like Ivy did, between two and three. Just like every other aspect of parenting, my expectations were totally OFF! And I had many strange preconceived notions of women who breastfed toddlers and preschoolers-- that they were hippies, super cheap, crazy religious, and just plain weird. I was a big, fat, ignorant JUDGER. My nine-plus years of parenting, and seven years of teaching, have softened me considerably, and I find myself accepting of pretty much any lifestyle that makes a family functional and happy. My years of judging and stereotyping are over. But when I unexpectedly found myself in a "category" of parents that I once found bizarre, I worried a lot that I would be judged.
I learned to nurse discreetly- but not secretly- when Sydney was only a few months old. Not to toot my own horn, but I am a PRO at public nursing (obviously, I have a few years of practice). Nonetheless, I stopped nursing Isadora in public right around 18 months-- when she started looking and acting more like a toddler than a baby. I stopped nursing her in front on anyone but my own kids and husband shortly after she turned two. I had mixed feelings about this-- I was not ashamed of what I was doing; I knew it was a healthy and universal experience, and in the best interest of myself/my baby/my family, but I realized that I just did not want to publicize my choice. Breastfeeding a toddler is neither fashionable nor understood, and I did not want to have to defend myself against uneducated, haughty people who disagreed with my choice, and somehow felt that it personally affected them.
Ivy is my only child who weaned herself. She just stopped asking, and it was wonderful and organic and satisfying and peaceful. I was really hoping Isadora would do the same thing, but she was what our pediatrician calls an "avid nurser." I call her a boobaholic. Even after weaning, she still puts her hand down my shirt for comfort. I can't really blame her, it is warm and soft down there. Our breastfeeding relationship was full of emotional ups and downs, as she wanted to do it ALL THE TIME, and I DIDN"T. Bryce and I made the decision to wean her when I decided I was ready to be totally done, and could not tolerate the idea of continuing indefinitely. That aspect of our relationship needed to change.
Weaning Isadora was not easy, but it was not horrible, either. She continued to ask for "momo" (her code-word for nursing) for at least a month after we were done, but since she was so old, she could be reasoned and negotiated with, so it was relatively painless. Considering how attached she was, I think the whole process went pretty smoothly. I am content with the course we took with all three girls, but until now, I felt strangely awkward discussing it with anyone but my closest friends, and other women I know who have made similar choices.
I don't want to feel awkward. If breastfeeding is ever going to become accepted for babies of all ages, "regular" folks like me need to talk about it. We need to NOT be afraid to share our experience. I am most comfortable writing about it here, and being more open about it with other friends, in context. Extreme enthusiasm about the cause seems unsuitable, because I think it will scare people away. So here I am. Sharing with you that I am not a vegan (but I do use vegan butter), nor do I make my own clothes (because I am The Anti-Crafter), live on a farm or in Africa, buy only organic cotton, drive a hybrid car (although I would like one), let my children call me by my first name, or any of the other stereotypes associated with "crunchy granola" parents. But I believe that long-term breastfeeding is a healthy, appropriate option that I am no longer afraid to share that we chose.
If it makes people squeamish, oh well. Raw oysters make me squeamish, but if you really love them, go ahead and eat up.